I took my young kids on a Disney Cruise, but Royal Caribbean became my favorite after just one voyage. Here's why.
In:Disney and Royal Caribbean are two of the most family-friendly cruise lines at sea. Both have devout followers, with many arguing that one is better than the other. Recently, one family finally decided to try Royal Caribbean and shared why they'd be hesitant to sail with Disney again.

Disney Cruise Line is known for its immersive theming, unique rotational dining, and one-of-a-kind character experiences. On the flip side, Royal Caribbean is known for its innovative ships, thrilling attractions, and a wide variety of activities for all travelers. And although both cruise lines cater to families, they offer very distinct vacation experiences.
Disney, for instance, doesn't have any mega-ships packed with roller coasters, zip lines, or ropes courses sailing out of North America or Europe. The most exciting attraction on its Wish Class ships, including Disney Wish, Disney Treasure, and Disney Destiny, is the AquaMouse, and even that pales in comparison to the waterslides aboard Icon, Star, and Legend of the Seas.
"My most recent Disney cruise was in April and we just got off Royal Independence of the Seas yesterday and honestly overall we preferred this for our almost 2 and 4 year olds. I cant even imagine how much better some of the bigger boats would’ve been since they offer even more kid friendly spaces," shared Purple_Grass_5300 on the r/royalcaribbean Reddit thread.

Continuing on, they said, "Everybody said Disney is known for exceptional staff but the staff on Royal were much more attentive during dining and around the boat in general too. Refills came much faster, they’d even wash my youngests bottle at dinner and give us a fresh bottle of milk on our way out... Everybody was [also] super friendly from other passengers to staff. I feel like they were much more sociable on this cruise than [on] Disney."
The parents also preferred Royal Caribbean's main dining, which is less structured than Disney's formal rotational dining. For starters, Disney doesn't offer a flexible dining option for families, and the meal is usually centered around a themed show or interactive experience.
"I think the 5pm dining also made it easier since our youngest goes to bed at 630, so being outta there by 6 was a big difference compared to our Disney cruises where dinner always took 1.5hr and one night even took 2hrs on our most recent trip," they explained.

"It was also nice that we literally were the first table in [the] dining room without asking so that made a difference [compared to] Disney where we had a longer walk and couldn’t bring strollers. I liked the option of having my stroller because then it made bringing bottles, wipes, etc much easier too."
Others in the Reddit thread agreed, arguing that Royal Caribbean offers better value than Disney Cruise Line, with the latter rarely being worth the extra cost.
"Prefer [Royal Caribbean] over [Disney Cruise Line (DCL)]. DCL is overhyped and overpriced. The food and entertainment [are] better on [Royal Caribbean]," said Icy_Paramedic778.

Pusheen_The_Limit added, "For spring break we did a back to back Utopia [of the Seas] to the Disney Wish with our 5 y.o., and it was enlightening to compare the experiences so close together."
Here are three other reasons the original Redditor, Purple_Grass_5300, thought Royal Caribbean's Independence of the Seas was a better fit for their family than Disney Cruise Line.
Read more: I spent two days in Disneyland Paris and it reminded me how much better a value cruises are
Their kids preferred Splashaway Bay

Splashaway Bay is a popular amenity on many Royal Caribbean ships, providing younger kids with a dedicated area to cool off with slides, water cannons, and other interactive features.
On Independence of the Seas, Splashaway Bay is located steps from Baby Bay, which is for young children who aren't fully potty trained. Because they aren't allowed in the main pools, this area gives infants and toddlers their own place to splash and play on warm-weather sailings.
"I preferred [the splash area on Royal Caribbean] for my 4 year old over Disney’s since she loved the 2ft pool and it was close enough to baby zone that I could stand in one spot and see both of them, Purple_Grass_5300 said.

"Yes Disney’s splash for babies is much bigger but my 2 year old didn’t care and was happily going down the slide over and over. Again this never seemed crowded, for awhile we were the only babies but at most we’d see 4 other little ones."
There were other activities they could enjoy together

Outside of the Splashaway Bay area, Purple_Grass_5300's family spent time at the mini-golf course and the Sky Climber course. Plus, their oldest child got to do karaoke three times!
"The kids fun festival was [also] cute with free face painting and balloon animals," they added.
They spent more time utilizing the Adventure Ocean facilities

For families with younger children, there's no denying the benefit of sailing on a ship with a top-tier kids' club. Generally speaking, Disney and Royal Caribbean are considered two of the best in the industry, offering age-appropriate programming and dedicated play spaces for no extra charge.
Based on their experiences, Purple_Grass_5300 thought Royal Caribbean's Adventure Ocean spaces were more versatile and usable for their family.
"The living room space was great to kill time and relax a bit with toys that changed up a little each day. The space never seemed crowded, most of the time we’d be the only ones in there and at most there were 3 of us in there. Yes Disney’s toddler room is much fancier but when you compare 1hr a day vs 9am-10pm everyday, it’s a huge difference," they explained.

Purple_Grass_5300's family also utilized Royal Caribbean's toy-lending program, which allowed them to borrow a bag of toys from the nursery and swap them out during the sailing.
"Both kids liked them and it helped me pack less knowing we’d have toys on board," they added.
That said, Purple_Grass_5300 wishes that Royal Caribbean's ships had better technology when it came to the kids' clubs. For instance, Disney can send messages directly to your mobile phone when a child is ready to be picked up. On Independence of the Seas, the kids' club could only call the stateroom phone.
"It seemed kinda useless for me to use them since they only call your room if your kid needs to be picked up, so my original plan on having the youngest nap while I swam or did slides with my oldest wouldn’t work out. But it was still fine because she loved kids club so I ended up dropping her off there while our youngest napped in the room," they said.
In the end, they still plan on sailing with Disney for special themed cruises but will likely move solely to Royal Caribbean in the future

There were some aspects of a Disney cruise that Purple_Grass_5300 missed during their sailing on Independence of the Seas, including the "magic moments, the shows, [and] fireworks."
However, with children so young, they didn't know what they were missing and were just happy to be on a cruise. Plus, it was easier to get them into bed by 7:00 or 8:00 p.m. each day, which was a huge advantage compared to Disney.
"Overall, I still plan on doing DCL for Merrytime, Halloween and a Pixar day but afterwards I probably will just stick to Royal for all other cruises," they concluded.











































































































