I tried Royal Caribbean's controversial $520 VIP add-on. While some perks were nice, it was a waste of money
In:After giving Royal Caribbean's VIP add-on pass a try on my recent Wonder of the Seas cruise, I understand the critics more than the fans.

The Key is an optional purchase that includes certain benefits, such as internet access, reserved seating in the theaters, an exclusive welcome lunch in the Main Dining Room, priority ship-to-shore departure at tender ports of call, and more.
After over one dozen cruises with the family-friendly cruise line, I decided to finally splurge on the pricey add-on since it was my partner's first Oasis Class cruise. Sailing on one of the world's largest ships, I wanted to make the experience even more special.
Plus, we both needed Wi-Fi for work, so it was easier to justify the extra cost since The Key includes one VOOM Surf & Stream package per person. In total, The Key came out to $517.86 for our 7-night cruise on Wonder of the Seas from Port Canaveral, Florida.

However, because Oasis Class ships are too big to use tenders, that was one less perk off the bat. Instead, I focused on making use of our onboard perks.
While I appreciated dropping off my carry-on backpack and having reserved seating, I didn't feel the price was worth it and wouldn't purchase The Key again.
Embarkation was easy without using The Key's priority terminal access

On embarkation day, we took a Lyft from our hotel in Orlando to the airport to catch our pre-arranged shuttle bus through Go Port. Because the earliest shuttle wasn't scheduled to depart until 10:00am, I knew we wouldn't be the first passengers inside the terminal.
However, I was worried that since we were missing the Key's priority arrival, we'd be turned away since we had a 1:00pm check-in time. Thankfully, my concerns were unfounded, as we were welcomed into the terminal with no issue.
Overall, our embarkation process was smooth, which was a direct reflection of the efficiency of the team at Port Canaveral, rather than The Key itself. We were onboard the ship within fifteen minutes of stepping foot inside the terminal.
The exclusive welcome lunch was nice

Although it was only 11:30am, we headed straight to the Main Dining Room to drop off our heavy carry-on bags and sit down for the exclusive lunch.
We walked straight up to the check-in desk, where crew members tagged our backpacks and asked if we were ready to eat. We thought about returning an hour later but decided to go ahead and eat before the crowds arrived.
A helpful crew member immediately escorted us to a private table for two, though another couple was seated extremely close soon thereafter. It felt strange considering how many other seats were available, but it didn't ruin the experience.

The menu wasn't as large as the standard dinner menu; however, it included a decent variety of options. I was a little disappointed to see that there wasn't a dedicated vegetarian entrée.
Though I was content with a shrimp cocktail and filet mignon, my partner didn't find the options as appealing as someone who doesn't eat red meat. Instead, she ordered two appetizers and a dessert.
My filet mignon was cooked well, and my partner’s Caesar salad and shrimp cocktail appetizers were fine.

The best course was the New York Cheesecake, though having both lived in the Big Apple, it still fell short.
Generally speaking, the quality of the exclusive lunch didn't seem on par with what was advertised to help justify the expensive VIP experience.
While at lunch, we pursued the sheet given us to during check-in about all the benefits available to us during our 7-night cruise which included:

- Carry-on luggage drop-off on Deck 4 until 1:30pm on embarkation day + delivery straight to our cabin
- Exclusive welcome lunch in the Main Dining Room featuring the Chops Grille menu
- Private hours at ship activities
- Dedicated reserved seating at shows in the theater, AquaTheater, and Studio B
- One VOOM Surf & Stream Wi-Fi package per cruiser
- À la carte breakfast on disembarkation day from 6:30am to 8:30am
Being able to drop off our bags was the best embarkation day perk

Our carry-on bags were heavier than usual since we both brought on a bottle of wine to save money on drinks during our weeklong cruise.
As such, I was extremely grateful I didn't have to keep my backpack on my person while waiting for our stateroom.
Instead, we utilized The Key's drop-off program. All we had to do was give the crew members our cabin number, and they tagged our bags. We didn't see them again until they were delivered to our stateroom.

The Cruise Director came over the PA system around 1:00pm to announce that our cabins were finally ready, so we made our way to the cabin I booked on Deck 9 only to find that our backpacks weren't there yet.
What was there, however, was a fresh fruit place with grapes, an apple, a pear, and a banana. This felt a little wasteful, as most of the fruit went uneaten.
I would have preferred a form asking whether we wanted a plate and what our fruit preferences were. Alas, we weren't in a suite, so we got what was provided.

Rather than waiting around in our interior cabin for our carry-on bags, we decided to take advantage of the ship's amenities and explore our home for the next week!
My partner used one of her daily Diamond drink vouchers for a cocktail at Trellis Bar while taking in the sights of Central Park. She couldn't believe she was on a cruise ship!
By the time we returned around 2:00pm, our bags had been delivered and placed directly on the bed.

Truthfully, the delay wasn't a huge deal. I would have preferred to be slightly inconvenienced without my bag for a short time than have to carry it on my back for hours!
The reserved seating and exclusive activity times required advance planning and was somewhat inconvenient

If you've ever sailed on an Oasis Class ship, you know that cruisers are serious about their shows. Whether it's a theater production or a high-diving spectacle, expect passengers with (or without) reservations to line up at least 45 minutes before showtime.
Initally, the reserved seating excited me, as I typically end up on the far left or right of the AquaTheater. This time, we were guaranteed seats in the middle of the AquaTheater, which felt like a real treat—or it did until our show was canceled due to weather.
As we funneled out of the Boardwalk, we hastily made our way to Studio B to salvage our night with the ice skating show. Since we didn't have reservations, we couldn't take advantage of the reserved seating since it was full when we arrived.

Still, I thought we found great seats considering the ice skating show wasn't on our agenda until later in the week.
That said, Royal Caribbean handled our canceled AquaTheater show incredibly well. Instead of having passengers scramble to find last-minute reservations for one of the existing shows, they added a separate showtime on Day 5 and automatically moved our reservation.
As such, we finally got to try the reserved seating for inTENse. Though it was a nice perk, it wasn't game-changing. We could have scored similar seats by lining up early (and for a lot less money!).

Another benefit of The Key is private time for certain activities. However, we found the exclusive times inconvenient.
Note, Royal Caribbean has since changed this benefit. Instead of a free Flowrider time, it's now just a discount on these sort of activities.
I prefer to experience onboard activities during the day, freeing up my nights for relaxing dinners, shows, and listening to live music—we didn't want to do the FlowRider at 7:30pm at night after freshening up for dinner!
The only reserved time we took advantage of was the zip line on Day 7 after we showed up to grab seats for a game show in Spotlight Karaoke only to realize it was already full.

The zip line had no wait, which was nice as we were harnessed up and flying over the Boardwalk before we knew it! We could have ridden it again but once was enough for us.
Easy disembarkation experience

Overall, The Key's disembarkation experience was about the same as the regular process. On the second-to-last night of our cruise, our cabin attendant left us special light blue disembarkation tags for our luggage.
After packing our suitcases, we left our luggage in the hallway on the final evening and didn't see it again until we had made our way off the ship and to the luggage pick-up zone.
In terms of the actual disembarkation, we skipped the private breakfast in favor of specialty lattes from Cafe Promenade. It felt silly to budget extra time in our morning to grab breakfast that we really did not want!

Instead, after grabbing our coffee, we joined the short line to get off Wonder of the Seas. We passed through customs & immigration, collected our bags, and were waiting for our return Go Port bus by 7:45am.
Though The Key didn't really make a difference for us, I could see the separate disembarkation line useful if trying to get off closer to 8:15 or 8:30am.
While certain perks made the cruise experience feel more special, The Key wasn't worth it

There's no denying that dropping off our carry-on bags was a huge benefit that made embarkation day less stressful. However, the majority of the perks didn't justify the cost.
For example, instead of spending money on The Key, I'd rather splurge on individual experiences, like a specialty meal on embarkation day—I'm certain Giovanni's would have been better than our mediocre MDR lunch!
Additionally, I think it's easy to line up for shows ahead of time and grab decent seats—and that doesn't cost anything extra!

Though I felt special with the little key icon of my SeaPass, it certainly wasn't worth the $500+ we paid, even with Wi-Fi included.