I cruised on new ships from Disney and Royal Caribbean. Both have their strengths, but Royal Caribbean's value can't be overlooked
In:As an adult, I've come to appreciate that both Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean have their strengths, but one consistently offers a better value.
My first-ever cruise was aboard the Disney Magic. However, my family soon turned to Royal Caribbean because of its jaw-dropping ships and competitive pricing, primarily opting for ships like Freedom of the Seas and Oasis of the Seas instead of Disney Dream or Disney Fantasy.
Disney Cruise Line delivers an immersive, detail-oriented experience that feels magical from the moment you arrive at the terminal. On the flip side, Royal Caribbean tends to focus more on massive, innovative ships packed with engineering feats.
Within the past year, I've sailed on two of the newest ships at sea: Icon of the Seas and Disney Destiny. As much as I would have loved for them to be paid media voyages, every aspect of the trips was paid for with my hard-earned money, meaning I observed what worked, what didn't, and how each vacation stacked up in terms of overall value.

Although I found myself trying to plan another Disney cruise before disembarkation day, there is no denying that Royal Caribbean's Icon of the Seas delivered the stronger overall value, especially when factoring in the included dining options, entertainment, and onboard amenities.
In the end, comparing a Disney cruise and a Royal Caribbean cruise is a little like comparing apples to oranges. Still, both are highly family-friendly cruise lines that have solid entertainment lineups alongside well-designed adults-only spaces and experiences.
Here's how my two experiences aboard Icon of the Seas and Disney Destiny stacked up — and why I don't think you can actually go wrong with either of them (sorry, Matt!).
In April 2024, I sailed on a seven-night cruise on Icon of the Seas from Miami, Florida.
Royal Caribbean's Icon Class is advertised to deliver the "ultimate family vacation," featuring amenities like the largest water park at sea, countless dining options, and around-the-clock entertainment.
Despite clearly being built for families, my fiancée and I wanted in on the action, so we booked a seven-night Eastern Caribbean cruise in April 2024, calling at ports like Perfect Day at CocoCay, St. Thomas, and St. Kitts and Nevis.
Icon of the Seas was not cheap when she launched, and you'll still struggle to find affordable vacations on the massive vessel. Knowing that, we booked our trip nearly 16 months in advance to give ourselves plenty of time to budget and prepare.
Even still, our Neighborhood GTY stateroom cost over $3,800, breaking down to roughly $542 per night. Once we factored in travel-related expenses and optional add-ons like shore excursions, a drink package, unlimited specialty dining, and Wi-Fi, our total vacation cost was around $7,456.
While it wasn't the cheapest cruise, it definitely could have been more expensive had we gone with an ocean-view balcony, and in the end, we weren't too unhappy with the cost, which came to about $932 per night (including the night we flew to Florida) for one of the newest and most impressive ships at sea.
Around a year later, I went on a short four-night Bahamian voyage on Disney Destiny from Fort Lauderdale, Florida.

Being a cruise writer isn't all fun and games. At times, it can be difficult to separate work from play and create a healthy work-life balance. So, when planning my birthday cruise, I knew I wanted an experience that would be vastly different from the other countless voyages I'd covered for Royal Caribbean Blog and Cruise Blog.
Enter Disney Destiny, Disney Cruise Line's newest Wish Class ship, sailing from Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Like my vacation on Icon of the Seas, I knew a Disney cruise wouldn't be a cheap getaway, so we booked our four-night voyage in January 2025, or 16 months in advance.
We reserved a Category 5C Deluxe Oceanview Stateroom with Verandah for $3,125. This came out to around $781 per night, or $239 more expensive than my neighborhood infinite veranda on Icon of the Seas.

In the end, we spent nearly $5,570 on the cruise fare, travel-related expenses, souvenirs, port adventures, and an unlimited thermal spa pass (which was SO worth it, by the way), or $928 per night.
The short Bahamas cruise was not the most affordable vacation I have ever taken, but I was celebrating my 27th birthday along with several other personal and professional milestones, so I decided the splurge was worth it — even if I could have stretched my budget further on other lines or a land-based trip.
Both ships offer a ton of different dining options, from poolside tacos to upscale steakhouses.
Food is undeniably one of the most important parts of a cruise — and you can't go wrong with Icon of the Seas or Disney Destiny for quality and variety.
That said, each ship has its strengths. Whereas Disney Cruise Line's themed dining rooms focus on immersive, character-driven stories, Royal Caribbean offers a more flexible main dining approach.
With Royal Caribbean’s "My Time" (or "anytime") dining, guests can make reservations for the Main Dining Room around their own schedule, whereas Disney only offers two traditional, fixed seating times each evening.
Moving on, Royal Caribbean's specialty dining is family-friendly, giving guests a wider range of upscale options that everyone can enjoy together — from Teppanyaki to Italian, seafood, and more.
On the other hand, Disney's specialty restaurants are strictly adult-only (and highly exclusive). Scoring a reservation for Palo can seem impossible if you don't hold status with the line — or book a pricey Concierge suite.
Still, after over three dozen cruises on multiple lines, Palo stands out as one of the best meals I have ever had at sea, easily surpassing high-end venues like Celebrity's Le Voyage. So, yeah, it's worth the hype (if you can get in).

When it comes to complimentary dining variety, Icon of the Seas features a wider range of included venues, from the AquaDome Market food hall to grab-and-go options from Pearl Café, El Loco Fresh, and multiple buffets.
However, Disney Destiny also has a good amount of complimentary offerings, especially for a ship of its size. In addition to the Marceline Market buffet, Mickey & Friends Festival of Foods is an outdoor food court with five different stalls, ranging from Mexican to BBQ, pizza, and more.
Either way, I was impressed with both vessels, and it's easy to sail on either without spending extra money on special restaurants.
Disney has pricey Wi-Fi packages that are almost impossible to justify.

Neither Disney nor Royal Caribbean includes Wi-Fi in their cruise fares. However, Royal Caribbean's internet packages are easier to justify from a value standpoint, especially if they're purchased during a pre-cruise sale.
For example, I paid just $21.99 for Royal Caribbean's VOOM Surf + Stream ahead of time through the Cruise Planner.
Comparatively, Disney doesn't offer any pre-cruise sales, and I was shocked to see the base package priced at $27 per night aboard Disney Destiny.

For full web browsing and streaming capabilities, I would have had to shell out nearly $150 on a four-night cruise. Instead, we took advantage of Disney's free messaging ability (which allows guests to use iMessage and WhatsApp for no extra charge) and only connected to cellular in port for $12/day.
Entertainment-wise, Disney Destiny and Icon of the Seas are two of the best ships at sea, but Royal Caribbean has more variety.
Moving on, Royal Caribbean's entertainment lineup is more diverse, featuring high-diving productions in the AquaTheater, ice skating shows, and Broadway-style musicals.
Disney's entertainment is also top-tier. However, they focus primarily on Broadway-style theater productions.
I can't say that I saw a bad show on either ship. Disney's Hercules really went the distance on the Disney Destiny and had a unique, soulful element through the talent of the Muses.

Frozen was also a cute production, though a little gimmicky, trying to use too much modern slang and contemporary humor to appeal to younger kids.
Finally, Disney Seas the Adventure was exactly the kind of production you'd want to see on a Disney cruise. It featured beloved characters like Goofy and Minnie and was packed with energy, music, and Disney magic.
As much as I love Broadway-style musicals, theater shows aren't for everyone. If you prefer action-packed entertainment and a wider variety of performances, Royal Caribbean's Icon of the Seas takes the cake.
The AquaTheater show was especially impressive, featuring skateboarders and acrobatic tricks set against an indoor waterfall!
Disney's verandah cabins are sleek, elegant, and ideal for families.

Even on its oldest ships, Disney Cruise Line is known for maximizing comfort and functionality for families. As such, I much preferred my stateroom aboard Disney Destiny.
For starters, the cabin was elegantly designed and had subtle magical touches throughout the stateroom without the decor feeling overly themed.
However, the best part about my Disney cruise cabin was the split bathroom, which separated the shower and bathtub from the toilet area.

The toilet and sink were in the room closest to the cabin door, while the shower/tub combo and main sink were located in the next room.
I loved this layout because it was so much easier to get ready, and my fiancée and I noticed that there was more storage than in standard cruise bathrooms.
Moreover, the shower itself felt luxurious with white tile, premium sea salt bath products, and a rainfall showerhead.

Although neither of us used the tub, this is undoubtedly a huge advantage for families with younger children, too.
Moving on, there was nothing inherently wrong with my Central Park infinite verandah on Icon of the Seas, but it was the small touches in the Disney Destiny cabin that made it stand out.
For example, while many went ballistic over the changes to Icon Class bathrooms, I found Disney's split layout more practical for families — that's not to say I didn't love the extra-large shower!
Additionally, the cabin itself felt a little more cookie-cutter and lacked the same attention to detail found in my room aboard Disney Destiny.
I also missed having a real balcony, and because we faced the interior of the ship, we felt more exposed and less connected to the ocean.
For example, whenever we returned for an afternoon nap, we closed the blinds to keep guests in other cabins from looking directly into our cabin. As such, we also didn't benefit from the same level of natural light that generally floods an ocean-view room.
This, of course, is a bit of an unfair comparison since I had an ocean-facing balcony on Disney Destiny. However, had I gone with the standard ocean verandah on Icon, we would have had to shell out nearly $3,000 more for our weeklong cruise – and we wouldn't justify that.
My Royal Caribbean drink package meant I didn't have to worry about racking up a large bill on drinks.
Royal Caribbean has three different drink packages to choose from, giving passengers the ability to tailor their experience based on their drinking habits.
My fiancée and I opted for the Deluxe Beverage Package, and for around $1,000, we enjoyed unlimited cocktails, soda, specialty coffee, bottled water, and more during our Icon of the Seas cruise.
Having everything prepaid made it easy to order beverages without constantly thinking about running up a high onboard account.

On the flip side, Disney's base fare includes soda, which is a nice touch to help justify the higher price. However, they don't have any packages to bundle non-alcoholic or alcoholic drinks. Instead, you must pay for each one individually as you go.
For me, that ended up working perfectly. Since I've recently embraced sobriety, I wasn't looking to down a ton of cocktails by the pool anyway. Instead, the included soda was all I needed and eliminated the need for a drink package.
Still, since Disney does not offer any beverage packages, Royal Caribbean is more flexible for those who prefer to prepay for their drinks upfront.
Icon of the Seas offered way more to do onboard.
Finally, if you are looking for a ship with non-stop thrills, look no further than Icon of the Seas. This massive vessel features everything from the record-breaking Category 6 Waterpark to an ice skating rink, FlowRider surf simulator, rock climbing wall, mini-golf course, and more.





























































































